I’ve begun to rethink my research’s focus.
Growing up in San José, I was often upset by how hard local music seemed to be so difficult to come by. Most people listened to rock, pop, hip hop, and country–the kind of top-50 music you stuff you could not avoid on the radio if you tried, and no one I knew could be bothered to branch out. For those middle and high school kids who were interested, the big thing was to see bands play in the party room in the back of the Nickel City arcade. Of course, by the time I finally got in on it, it was already getting shut down (dancing was not allowed at my first show). My brother and I once drove as far as Cupertino just to see a band from our own school.
I always figured that this impression of scarcity was a result of my own inexperience, but since I have come back to town, sat down, and directly applied myself to seek out music in the city, I have come to rethink that. Through four weeks in San José, and I have only been to one show in the city. On top of that, in the entirety of Gimme Something Better, a book by Jack Boulware and Silke Tudor on the history of punk rock in the Bay Area, San José is not mentioned a single time while the south bay is only referred to twice, essentially to say that nothing was happening there.
This seems to remain the case; I’ve been able to find two shows in town (one of them 21+), and most of those musicians I have managed to see have been playing in San Francisco and Santa Cruz. The independent music and art festival, SADFEST 2KX5, coming up towards the end of May will take place over one night in Dublin, CA, and two in San José, yet only three of the twenty-eight bands announced are actually from the city. Compare this to any given night in Olympia, where there’s likely to be a handful of shows featuring plenty of locals. San José is the tenth largest city in the United States, with a population of just under a million, yet San Francisco (pop. 837K), Seattle (652K), Portland (609K), Oakland (406K), Berkeley (117K), Santa Cruz (63K), and Olympia (48K) all have much more impressive music scenes and musical histories. The question I inevitably have to ask is why is there so little music in San José, especially for a city its size.
I‘ve been considering and researching a number of factors that might contribute to this. For one thing, San José is a very big city (the tenth largest in the country), which may have a suffocating effect for would-be artists. For another, the layout and architecture of the city can feel very homogenous and uncompelling, which may impact its artistic psyche. Some of the people I have interviewed so far have pegged the lack of venues in recent years, which may be linked to a shift in population as the computer industry continues to draw in wealthy tech-types who’s interests–and money–may be oriented towards night club types of places. Wealth in general may be a factor, considering that San José has the most disposable income per household among large cities (population>500K) in the United States. Then again, some of these characteristics are recent developments. San Francisco has historically dominated San José, and with their renowned artistic and liberal reputations, San Francisco and Berkeley may act as vacuums or magnets that draw all the artistic people away from the south bay.
I will be addressing each of these ideas in more detail in upcoming posts. I regret that I have not been keeping up with my website. Between my car getting wrecked and an extensive series of complications and let-downs associated with that; trying to make sure that I don’t end up homeless again this Summer from two states away and a series of complication and let-downs associated with that; trying to actually get out and see music and a series of complications and let-downs associated with that; coming back to live with my parents and series of frustrations and complications associated with that; nursing and running errands for my dad, losing both of my cameras; and getting banged up a bunch since skateboarding has been my soul mode of transportation, my board is falling to pieces and the sidewalks in San José are trash… I have been feeling very overwhelmed and very disappointed. I’m out of my funk now though. I’ve got a car and a camera to use and a list of upcoming shows and festivals, and I’m going to be recording interviews and music. I’m back in it!

