In Search of Lost Time

The Evergreen State College

Author: Austin

Journal Entry #3 – La Captive and After Life

After Life and La Captive, the two films that I watched in class over the past two weeks seem to me to be very similar, both in subject matter and in execution. At a first glance these two films don’t seem to have all that much in common. With After Life focusing on how precious our memories are and what memory, when one were forced to do so, stands out among the rest as your most important, and La Captive spending it’s narrative following the crumbling relationship of a young couple who are enabling each other to live an unhealthy life there doesn’t seem to be any one thing that stands out like a beacon to the viewer to point to them being similar. But as we saw them both during our ten week quarter on the writings of Marcel Proust and the topic of memory I find myself inclined to believe that there are, in fact, many connections between the two films and, most likely, similar connections between every film and extra text that we have been assigned to view and read during this spring quarter.

One of the most present connections that I found linking After Life and La Captive together is that of the human placement and understanding of value and what things mean to us. In After Life  the whole goal of the two week long session is for each recently deceased person to place the most value on one specific memory and this placement of value varies in many ways. For some of the residents, the most valuable memory was when they felt the happiest, often when they were in the presence of a loved one but for others, mostly those who fail the initial memory selection process and stay on as caretakers, the value is harder to place. There is talk amongst these people of their life possibly lacking value or that picking one specific memory does a disservice to other, equally valuable aspects of their life. Eventually, the placement of value comes back to happiness, though containment may be a more appropriate term, when the protagonist chooses his one memory to be the memory of him looking at the people that were most important to him, the other caretakers. He felt happiest there and to the protagonist, true happiness lies in remembering the people that you shared your happiness with.

This connection can be seen in a very different light in La Captive where the couple, a paranoid man and a secretive woman, place the value of their lives in aspects separate from happiness, like control and escape but these placements of value are proven to be false and their true placement of value is revealed to also be that of happiness, or, even more appropriately, contentment.  The relationship, as toxic as it may seem, has worked for this couple so far because they have accepted the oddities of the other, albeit more the woman accepting that mans oddities, in order to lead a content life of knowing that things are unhealthy but feeling comfortable in the environment that they have built together. Unfortunately this too is a false placement of value on the couples part, specifically seen when the man decides that he can longer trust his partner and breaks it off and later when the woman, after getting back together with the man, swims out to sea and drowns. Both of them realize that the relationship is bad and both of them get to a breaking point in the personalities and lifestyles that just can’t allow them to continue the facade that they have created for themselves. It appears to me that both the man and the woman, though again more so the man, strive for comfort but only comfort for themselves and have little care of the other, though they often deny this fact. When it becomes to much the act out in an attempt to keep what comfort they have but because their sense of value has been lost due to the steady decline of their relationship they act out very irrationally and this sadly leads to the death of the woman.

What I am trying to explain is that both of these films put forth the idea that the most valuable thing in life, more so than happiness, comfort or success is who you spend your time with and how you spend that time with them. Whether we like it or not we are defined by those around us, unless we are alone and even then we may begin to draw definitions of ourselves and because of this it is incredibly important to be aware of who you spend your time with and how. La Captive shows that this couple doomed themselves by not accepting the fact that they were a bad combination to spend time together and After Life shows the bittersweet nature of the protagonist only finding the people he truly cared for after he had already died, and that because he didn’t spend enough time truly being where he was and with who he was in life, he was unable to choose the memory that best represented these feelings for him.

These connections may be widely inaccurate but I found it interesting to discuss nevertheless.

Journal Entry #4 – The Imagination of a Six Year Old

 

I am six years old. I am leaving my last day of class. I am in kindergarten. I am leaving kindergarten. I am becoming older, but I don’t want to. Walking down the hallway at Brown’s Point Elementary near the first grade wing of the school I see my friend Nate walking in his class line opposite mine. We always leave school in our class lines and separate once we get out to the parking lot. I look at Nate’s first grade class and how cool and tall they look and wonder how tall I will be when I’m a first grader. I take the blue school bus home most days. The bus isn’t actually blue but has a laminated paper with the word BLUE on it in blue print. I always wanted to take the orange bus home because that was my favorite color but that would take me up the hill towards Federal Way and the Aquatic center where I took swimming lessons. So I took the Blue School bus with my friend Matt. He lives several houses down from mine in Brown’s Point, WA. Matt is my best friend and, in the sport of being six, I often tell him fables (lies) about my life before coming to kindergarten, somehow convince that I anyone that the five years of my life prior to kindergarten are the most eventful years anyone has ever experienced.

I was born in Hawaii and lived there until I was four years old. I use this to tell all the kids in my class (mostly Matt) that I am interesting and that they should be my friends. I tell them that I am thousands of years old and am a pirate who washed up on the shore of Brown’s Point. I use a fake shipwreck sculpture that a house down the road from my parent’s house has in their front yard to solidify my story. To everybody I meet, that boat is what I took to get to Washington in August of 1998. To me at times, that boat is what I took to get to Washington in August of 1998.

I get off of the school bus at the bus stop in front of my house and walk with Matt up to the front door. He stays for dinner but only eats part of the bun of his hamburger and barely touches his corn. We play Bomberman 2 on the Super Nintendo that my father had hooked up in my room earlier that year. We jump up and down in frantic spurts, unaware of how to play this video game but loving it all the same. Matt walks down the street to his house and I eat his leftover hamburger (without the top bun with a bit mark in it of course).

My mom asks me how my last day of school was. I enjoyed it even though the other kid named Matt in my class kicked the teacher for some unknown reason and had to go to the principal’s office. I tell my mom that I don’t want to be in first grade in the fall and that I would rather stay in Ms. Nelson’s kindergarten class forever. I tell her that I want to be six years old forever. I tell her that I want to be a 3000-year-old pirate from Hawaii that sailed here on the boat at that house by the park. I cry and my mother is quiet. She tells me of a time when I was two, when she was putting away laundry and watching the old black and white version of the movie titanic on silent. She tells me of how I cry out when the men on the titanic begin to jump into the water. I yell, “Don’t jump in the water! It’s too cold! The daddies are jumping in the water and it’s too cold!”

My mother tells me about how she believes that I might have been one of those men on the titanic before I was born as Austin. At the start of first grade, I begin to tell my friends that before I was Austin, I was a 3000-year-old pirate who sailed around the Pacific Ocean, eventually landing in Brown’s Point and founding the town. The kids that I tell my story to are not like Matt. They don’t play games like Bomberman 2 or like The Land Before Time (The Land Before Time is a great film and I cannot believe that any child did not love it as much as I did it is ridiculous). The kids that I tell my story to don’t know how to react so they laugh. Not at me I think but at my story, as though I was telling a funny joke. For the rest of first grade I pretend to be the class clown. For the rest of first grade the kids keep telling me to stop making sound effect noises and star wars jokes.

 

 

Journal Entry #5 – Research on Wes Anderson

Wesley Anderson, professionally referred to as Wes Anderson, has been writing and directing films since his early childhood and has been known by the public since the late 1990’s. He has won several awards for his screenplays of The Royal Tenenbaums (2001), Moonrise Kingdom (2012) and The Grand Budapest Hotel (2014) and is well known for his quirky narrative style that emphasizes on uncomfortable truths in both plot structure and movement. For example, if a character in one of Wes Anderson’s films has to run down a long hallway it will take an uncomfortably long amount of time to do so.

Wes Anderson is well known among the public eye, even more so now due to the mass success of The Grand Budapest Hotel, mainly for his unique way of filming but also for his very common recasting of actors who have been in his previous films. For example, the actor Owen Wilson, whom Anderson met while attending college, has been cast in a whopping six out of Anderson’s eight full-length films while the actor Bill Murray has appeared in an even more impressive seven out of eight of Anderson’s works. Other commonly recast actors include: Adrien Brody (3 films), Willem Dafoe (3 films), Jeff Goldblum (2 films), Anjelica Houston (3 films), Harvey Kietel (2 films), Edward Norton (2 films), Jason Schwartzman (5 films), Tilda Swinton (2 films) and Luke Wilson (3 films).

Wes Andersons films are also widely known to be comically in a witty and, at times, very dry sense relying on over dramatization and bluntness to deliver most of the laughter. This style of writing is far out of the norm for a “popular” film maker and can definitely shy people away from his films at first but it is indeed worthwhile to get used to the formula as it has worked on so many occasions.

Recently, Anderson has been working on a multitude of short films after the release of The Grand Budapest Hotel but is rumored to be starting on another feature in the not too distant future. Regardless of what the film maker creates next, it is certain to be well attended by the public is if follows his recent success pattern as it should be.

 

Journal Entry #6 – A Reflection

This is the hardest class that I have taken at Evergreen and I couldn’t be happier to say that. I will miss this class a lot. To be completely honest I probably shouldn’t have taken this class because of the amount of work it required which was bound to clash with my work schedule and my scattered attempts at creating an independent lifestyle but I’m glad that I did because, while I’m exhausted after the ten weeks of this program, I feel like I have grown immensely and have a better grasp on how to plan my priorities.

My favorite thing about this class was the seminar time that we had on Monday and Wednesday. I felt like seminar was crucial to my understanding of Proust and I even started reading Proust out loud during the last two volumes because it seemed to help so much in seminar. I also really agree with what Stacey said on the last day of class about how this is an incredibly diverse program and I think that can really be seen in our seminar groups. I have been in seminar style classes a lot in the past five years and never before have I had a seminar that was both this diverse and this interesting. Usually if a group is too different things are too quiet or too chaotic but I feel like our seminar had a perfect balance of agreement and disagreement.

I plan on beginning a full read of In Search of Lost Time, hopefully getting through a full volume every 3-6 months (though I wouldn’t be surprised if it took a full year for each volume). I really enjoy Proust’s writing and I think it’s a great addition to the other authors (Sartre, Beckett, Hemingway, Woolf, Plath, etc.) that I plan on reading more of in the near future. I think I would have passed up on Proust if it wasn’t for this class, seeing the 4,000 pages of text and feeling like there just wouldn’t be enough time, but if I can get through nearly 2,000 pages in ten intense weeks I can definitely get through the full read in several years, if not less. I feel like I’ve learned more in this class than I am aware of, and I look forward to figuring out just what I have learned from this program.

A Close Reading for “The Captive” : Pg. 261-262 & 267-268

Throughout In Search of Lost Time the narrator spends most of his time in the company of upper-middle class and high class people, people who would have been aristocrats if the aristocracy was still intact, and often times discusses the importance that French Society, an Western Society in general, puts onto people of “good” standing, or people who are incredibly successful and wealthy. In The Captive, the narrator again comes to this notion of popularity and social standing as being the most important thing in a persons life. The narrator talks about the death of Swann and reads a paragraph from his obituary in a newspaper:

” ‘We learn with deep regret that M. Charles Swann passed away yesterday at his residence in Paris after a long and painful illness. A Parisian whose wit was widely appreciated, a discrimination but steadfastly loyal friend, he will be universally mourned, not only in those literary and artistic circles where the rare discernment of his taste made him a willing and welcome guest, but also at the Jockey Club of which he was one of the oldest and most respectful members. He belonged also to the Union and the Agricole. He had recently resigned his membership of the Rue Royale. His witty and striking personality never failed to arouse the interest of the public at all the great events of the musical and artistic seasons, notably at private views, where he was a regular attendant until the last few years, when he rarely left his house. The funeral will take place, etc.’ ”

This passage does its best to talk about Swann as a person, noting that he was very loyal to his friends and that he was witty and had a striking personality but the bulk of the paragraph actually focuses not on things that Swann did in his life or who Swann was but of what social groups he was a part of or of how the public viewed Swann at parties and events that he attended. One could argue that this things are what Swann did and who he was but as we have read, Swann lead quite the mysterious life in his earlier years, and more importantly there is no mention of Swann’s wife, Odette, or child, Gilberte, which can almost be guaranteed to be because of Odette’s social standing. If Swann truly did nothing of note besides going to these parties and being a part of these clubs then why is he such an influential person? It seems to me that, like a celebrity in modern times that isn’t actually a part of any profession, Swann is well known for the novelty of the public having someone to be well known in there midst, for that drama and intrigue that a public figure can bring to a society in a post-aristocratic era.

Unfortunately, the less well kept one’s title is in Paris, the less fondly remembered they are:

“From this standpoint, if one is not ‘somebody’ the absence of a well-known title makes the process of decomposition even more rapid. No doubt it is more or loss anonymously, without any individual identity, that a dead man remains the Duc d’uzes. But the ducal coronet does for some time hold the elements of him together, as their moulds held together those artistically designed ices which Albertine admired, whereas the names of the ultra-fashionable commoners as soon as they are dead, melt and disintegrate, ‘turned out’ of their moulds.”

It is in this passage that the narrator seals in that even though the aristocracy is technically dismantled, a aristocratic mindset still plagues Parisian society. It is proven here that in the eyes of the public, people without titles and wealth do not remain in this world after their passing, regardless of who the were as people and that even those with higher positions in society are not really remembered for who they were or even what they did but of who they knew and how they were seen.

The narrator falls into this category as well, unable to escape viewing Swann after his death as the public does instead of as he knew him.

“I felt that everything that had been told to me about the Verdurins was far too crude; and indeed in the case of Swann, whom I had known, I reproached myself for not having paid sufficient attention to him in a sufficiently disinterested spirit, for not having listened to him properly when he used to entertain me while we waited for his wife to come home for lunch and he showed me his treasures, now that I knew that he was to be classed with the most brilliant talkers of the past.”

Throughout In Search of Lost Time the importance of the technically unimportant aristocratic class is a major point of interest for the narrator and is explored in The Captive in a way that makes French society seem rather similar to American society in how it treats deceased celebrity and public figures in a manner that, more often than not, does not focus on who the person was or what morals they held but of who they knew and how they were viewed by the public.

 

 

Musical Pizza Time Stuff

I love music. I love to listen to music, to play music, to read about music. Oftentimes, I surround myself with music so much that I forget that it’s such a huge part of my life. Recently, I’ve been taking surveys online, for both my enjoyment and to make a small sum of money and oftentimes these surveys ask similar questions. Questions like: “How many times to you shop for groceries in a month?” or “How many video game consoles do you own?”. One question seems to come up more often then not goes like this: “How many hours a week do you spend listening to music?”.

I’m never able to give a truly accurate answer to this question, not one nearly as accurate as how many trips I take to the grocery store in a month at least (it’s two). After being presented with the question several times and responding inconsistently with answers ranging from “8 hours” to “around 20?” I decided to actually measure my time spent listening to music and my hour count was a bit surprising. It turns out that I listen to around 55 hours of music a week (at least for the week that I measured it). I’m sure this data would be far more accurate if I averaged it with other weeks of recorded time listening and if my measurement were exact (I mostly rounded up or down the minutes to 5 minute intervals) but I feel like it’s in the ballpark of how much time I usually spend listening to a tune in the background somewhere.

After realizing that I spend over two days of my 7-days-in-a-week life cycle listening to roughly 100 or so artists on my iPod and (seldom) on the radio I started to think about when and why I spent so much time doing this. It’s not like I spent all these hours only listening to music. In fact, a part from listening to calming music every once in a while at night to fall asleep, I rarely just sat down to listen to music. The one exception being the hour I gave to listen through Sufjan Steven‘s new album Carrie & Lowell, which had just released several days prior to my experiment. Overall, I spent most of my time (around 35 hours of it) listening to music on the way to school, from school, or during work (I spend my weekends delivering pizzas to the friendly folk of Northeast Tacoma). I asked myself why I listened to music so much in the car, instead of listening to the outside world or just basking in the silence of being alone and at work. Habit, is my guess. I do love music but more so I love comfort and having the freedom to choose specifically what I want to hear during the course of my day is a very comfortable thing to do that, after a while, just becomes my usual response to sitting in a car and driving somewhere. While I love music, I felt like I was missing out on being present in the world and have decided to roll my window down and listen to what is outside every once in a while. I feel like that can be music too, in a cheesy what is life sort of way, and I want to see how a release from that part of technology effects my feelings.

I’m sure that I have many other habits and hobbies that take up more time that I think that they do and ,though I don’t know what they are yet, I intend to find out.

 

– Austin

 

Journal #1 – Thoughts of Swann

At the beginning of my reading of Swann’s Way, when I first started to hear of M. Swann, I was intrigued. He was mysterious and unorthodox, straying away from high society with such care that almost nobody knew that he was living multiple lives. In actuality, this type of person and this type of lifestyle is not all that uncommon (at least in my experience) but it was the way that we heard about M. Swann through the eyes and ears of the narrator that made him more interesting to me that other people that I have read about and met in the two decades of my existence. It was wonderful hearing about him through the inaccurate conversation held by the narrators family and by the narrators own recollections and assumptions but when the novel transitioned into Swann In Love and we began to see more detail about M. Swann’s life I have to admit that I was disappointed. Not in the novel, but in M. Swann himself.

M. Swann doesn’t appear to be honest with himself in really any aspect. Maybe this is because it’s not really told through his point of view or maybe that is just how people acted in Parisian society of that time but M. Swann does not appear to be this unconventional man that we had been told he was. Instead, M. Swann appears to be no better than his high class associates and possibly even worse. I say this because while the high class of Paris that we are told about in the novel appear to be rather manipulative and impersonal at least they are being this way to each other and are aware of the intricate details of high class social politics. M. Swann, on the other hand, is acting this way towards everybody that he finds interest in, most of whom are of a lower class than his own. It seems poor of his character to interact with people this way because, as it appears to me, M. Swann is not separating himself from high society because he actually enjoys the company of middle and low class citizens but because he can get more of what he wants from them and with far less accountability.

Turning Point #1

Austin Milner

In Search of Lost Time

Turning Point Essay

 

The Three-Month Long “Cold”

 

In the late summer of 2012, just after returning from a summer camp that I was a counselor at, I caught a cold. It was nothing to out of the ordinary, with the usual coughing and running nose, so my mother and I addressed the illness as usual, with a movie marathon, a bowl of chicken noodle soup, and a handful of saltine crackers. I admit, it was unusual for me to catch a cold in the summer season but I had assumed that I had gotten it from a camper that I worked with or something of that nature. In the early fall of 2012, anxiously on my way to my first day of my senior year of high school, I still had that cold.

I had quite the line-up of classes, projects, events and goals to conquer during my first semester of that senior year and was not about to let some silly cold get in the way of what the world had explained to me as the most important and enjoyable time in my life. I had just started dating someone and was in the process of founding a theatre club for my school and discovering a passion for writing. Missing school and social interactions didn’t seem worth it to me, even if it meant that my sickness would linger a tad longer but when my sickness refused to subside in the weeks to come, my mother decided to take me to the doctor’s office. “It’s just that time of year”, he said. We reassured him that a sickness lasting for about a month now was indeed out of the ordinary but this didn’t seem to change his diagnoses that I just had that seasonal fall cold. So we went home, I ate my chicken noodle soup and saltine crackers, finished up my 8-season marathon of Weeds and continued on with my “cold”.

It quickly became apparent to me that my sickness was getting worse. It seemed like every day in October added another symptom and, in addition to coughing and having a runny nose, I now was experiencing cold sweats, constantly fluctuating in body temperature, losing weight, feeling weak and had daily asthma attacks (I did not have asthma before the sickness began). I was unable to go to school. I rarely saw my friends. I became too depressed to write and I continued to eat chicken noodle soup and saltine crackers while binge watching shows on Netflix. The fun of a day off from school because I was sick was gone and every visit to the doctor’s office yielded the same response. I remember one day in particular, when I drove to school after finally getting my driver’s license on my eighteenth birthday and parked on a hill above the UW campus in downtown Tacoma. As I was walking to my statistics class I began to feel incredibly weak and collapsed onto the sidewalk. I deduced that I was unable to walk down to my class, let alone pay attention to my teacher’s lesson and then walk back up the hill to my car at the end of the day. So I got back on my feet and walked up the brief incline to my car and started it up but before I could put the car in drive I experience yet another asthma attack, not my first of the day and it was still morning, and was unable to breath for the next minute and a half. As I watched the minute on my cars cassette tape clock change I believed that I was going to die. Here in my car, without an inhaler for help because the doctor never prescribed one to me, I managed to take another breath. I put the car in drive and made my way back to my parent’s house to tell them that something was seriously wrong and that I needed to go to the doctors yet again.

We got the same response from the doctor, though this time with a little more concern because it was late October and I’d been sick since August. My mother and I decided at this point to see a naturopath near our home, giving up all hope on our usual doctor (I have not gone to see him since). We visited the naturopath for the first time near Halloween of that year and I was weighed at 105 lbs. We took a blood test and found out that I was severely allergic to gluten. The more gluten I ate the worse my immune system became and the harder it was for my to properly digest my food. The chicken noodle soup and saltine crackers turned out to be the culprit all along. Over the course of the next seven months I was able to finish my schooling on a high note, even accidently being awarded honors at Stadium High School (a school that I had attended for my freshman year only) and gained most of my weight back. I was glad for a happy ending to this chapter of my life but I felt foolish all the same. I knew something was wrong but I didn’t make any active effort to change how I was feeling.

In realizing that I had been living with an illness for three months when I could have prevented it with a simple blood test or some deductive reasoning I learned that I wasn’t really taking care of myself and that I was putting my goals in front of my health. I had a habit of letting things build up until I would be forced to deal with them. I needed to change the way that I interacted with the world and how I reacted to the things that were in my life, whether it be an allergy to gluten or how to balance my hobbies with school and work. I was becoming an adult and would be heading to college soon and would have even more things to juggle.

This realization is universal I am sure but the way that I came about it with my turning point caused me to go into the beginnings of my adult life with more caution and forethought. I don’t know if this is the best way that I could have started off my independent journey but I can surely say that gluten is the culprit for how I’ve shaped myself, for better or for worse.